The Lively Cafe at St. John's

211 N Monroe St, Tallahassee, FL 32301, United States
+1 850-222-2636
$$$ Cafe
(62 Reviews)
Price Range $1–10

The Lively Cafe at St. John's is a quietly inviting spot nestled inside the fellowship hall of St. John's church, just a block or so from downtown Tallahassee’s hustle. This cafe leans into a casual, community-focused vibe—part lunch stop, part neighborhood convening place—where locals, office workers, and small groups find comfort in fresh, uncomplicated meals and a relaxed setting.

The menu is a rotating weekly selection, offering a balanced mix of sandwiches, salads, and sides that feel homemade and thoughtfully prepared. Popular choices like the Buffalo Chicken Sandwich and the Spicy Chicken Flatbread showcase their knack for hearty flavor without the fuss. Alongside these, the lighter options, including the Grilled Salmon Nicoise or the vegetarian-friendly Portabella with peppers and onions, make it easy to tailor a meal to different tastes or dietary needs. Many visitors appreciate the attention to portion size—the right amount to satisfy a midday hunger without leaving an overly heavy feeling.

One distinctive aspect is how The Lively Cafe blends convenience with comfort. The ordering process is straightforward, involving a pay window where cash is less common, fitting smoothly into a busy downtown lunch routine. The air conditioning on a hot, muggy Tallahassee day is a welcomed refuge, especially for those dashing in from the sun.

The atmosphere is lively but not overwhelming—fitting given the café’s name—and great for groups or solo diners who might want a quick bite or a casual meeting spot. It’s not a place for long, drawn-out meals but rather a setting where one can enjoy solid, deli-quality food either alone or in good company. Locals who have discovered it know that the quality extends beyond lunch: The option to pick up ready-to-heat homemade dinners aimed at two or four people offers a simple solution for busy evenings without sacrificing wholesome flavors.

The cafe’s setting inside a church fellowship hall gives it a comfortable, slightly unconventional charm—less polished than a typical downtown restaurant but more personal and lived-in. This makes The Lively Cafe particularly well-suited for anyone who wants a sense of community tied to their meal, whether it's a lunch break with coworkers, a club gathering, or an easy dinner option on a hands-off night.

Overall, The Lively Cafe at St. John’s fits into Tallahassee’s local fabric as a practical, friendly spot that delivers straightforward, fresh food and a no-pressure atmosphere—a dependable choice for a casual meal or a modest takeout dinner.

Highlights
Great tea selection
Popular for
Lunch
Solo dining
Good for working on laptop
What they serve
Coffee
Comfort food
Healthy options
Quick bite
Vegetarian options
Best for
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot

Openings Hours

Checking

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

11:00 AM - 01:30 PM

Wednesday

11:00 AM - 01:30 PM

Thursday

11:00 AM - 01:30 PM

Friday

11:00 AM - 01:30 PM

Saturday

Closed

Sunday

Closed

62 Reviews
gordon devoss

28 Dec 2025

Listen....how have y'all been keeping this place a secret!? Went today for the 1st time in 20+ years. It was super hot and muggy and the air conditioning was heavenly. Super nice ladies answered our questions and took our orders. Then you take your order card to the pay window (no cash i think) and square up. The food was deli quality. Very fresh and good portion size. Great for lunch. The room is open seating at big tables. The vibe of the room kinda reminded me of the Wakulla Springs Lodge. They also have crazy take-and-bake meals (see my pics) but you need to order ahead from what I understand. Right downtown, great experience!

Sean Stephens

06 Dec 2025

What a nice find! Working downtown there 2 options both are delis. A friend filled me in with this extra option a block away, since I didn't know it was there. One look at the online menu and I was off. They have 4 rotating weekly menus and I ordered from the green menu. Pork Bahn mi sandwich with a side of red grapes. The side is included with the ridiculously low price and there are multiple options. With fresh cucumber, cilantro, daikon radish and pickled carrots this sandwich was legit. They make fresh soups and desserts of the day which I will explore on my next visits. The all volunteer staff was so friendly and the place was buzzing. It is on church grounds with stunning outdoor seating. I treated a friend and got two sandwich and side meals for the same price as one singular sandwich from the deli across the street! Do leave a nice cash tip as it goes to charity. I will continue to leave reviews for each visit. Bravo Lively Cafe, Bravo!

Nancy VanWilder

08 Nov 2025

I met for lunch with a club group of women. Yes we are lively and loud. The accommodations were perfect! Food was great and not only did I have a wonderful lunch, I decided to get dinner to go! Yes! They make up delicious homemade dinners for 2 or 4 people! All you do is heat them up! Lunch, dinner, was a real treat! Especially when it was my night to cook!!

Dr. MIchael Sue Jenefsky

06 Nov 2025

I ordered a black bean burger with cheese, bacon, avocado, arugula, and tomato. My side was the Lively Bean Salad. There was too much for me to eat, so I brought half of each home. The food was delicious. I will be going back. I highly recommend it.

Nydia N

23 Oct 2025

I feel like this place is a best kept secret! Cool little cafe-like spot inside the fellowship hall of St. John's church. They have a weekly, rotating menu and specials with the most delicious & unique selections. They always have a tasty vegetarian option too (even when I'm not trying to eat vegetarian). Their lively bean salad is my favorite side!

Mary Margaret Niezgoda

01 Oct 2025

One of my all-time favorite lunch spots! The menu rotates weekly, there are weekly specials (including delicious desserts), everything is made fresh, service is quick and friendly, prices are amazing, and you can order online! I've literally never had a bad meal there. It's a local Tallahassee gem, so you're guaranteed to see someone you know there. If you decide to eat there, go eat in the garden! I can't believe such a treasure is hidden in downtown Tallahassee!

Raychel G

12 Sep 2025

I didn’t even know about this cafe until my family ordered take out. I ordered the Buffalo chicken sandwich and it was great! Quality sandwich! I look forward to trying this place out again in the future.

Join the The Lively Cafe at St. John's Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.